What’s Driving Liability Verdicts?

Some jurisdictions have been labeled “judicial hellholes” by the American Tort Reform Foundation.
By David Tobenkin Posted on March 2, 2020

An affiliate, the American Tort Reform Foundation, has since 2002 documented jurisdictions that it terms “judicial hellholes,” in which, the foundation contends, “civil court judges systematically apply laws and court procedures in an unfair and unbalanced manner, generally to the disadvantage of defendants.”

The foundation’s 2018-2019 report names the following as the nation’s “most unfair” regions, courts and legislative bodies presiding over civil litigation.

  • California
  • Florida
  • New York City
  • St. Louis
  • Louisiana
  • Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas
  • New Jersey Legislature
  • Madison and St. Clair Counties, Illinois
  • St. Paul and Minneapolis, Minnesota

Wherever it occurs, social inflation, which is the tendency of jurors to award higher sums over time for successful tort liability claims, is an ongoing phenomenon that has little to do with the merits of the case—or even the law in some instances. There is no hard evidence identifying the specific reason for continuously escalating liability verdicts, but among theorized causes are:

  • General fatigue toward corporations and organizations
  • A belief, based on the high salaries of some executives, celebrities and others, that corporations have unlimited funds to settle litigation claims
  • A sense that wrongs in society must be righted
  • Greater attorney involvement in claims, which often lengthens the time frame of claims and their severity
  • Litigation financing, which provides more investor money to plaintiffs to fund liability litigation in exchange for a share of settlements.

Social inflation makes it more difficult to properly price liability insurance and, in some cases, write it altogether.

“We don’t believe we can get an adequate rate in many locations,” says Rob Francis, executive vice president for underwriting and operations of ProAssurance Corp. “There are states and locations in states where pricing has not reached the point where it adequately covers losses, and we are very wary to do business in some jurisdictions, such as West Virginia, that are known as plaintiff-friendly jurisdictions where it is difficult to defend.”

David Tobenkin Contributing Writer, Leader's Edge Read More

More in Industry

Keith Schuler Is Leading with the Long Game
Industry Keith Schuler Is Leading with the Long Game
Q&A with Keith Schuler, CEO of InterWest Insurance Services and 2024 Council Boa...
Industry Insurance Brokerage M&A Looks Toward a Rebound in 2024
Could the fourth quarter economic rebound in 2023 lead toward brighter days in 2...
Admitting I Don't Understand
Industry Admitting I Don't Understand
This year I’m leaning in to two themes that confound, terrify and engage me.