Health+Benefits

How Benefits Captives Help Brokers Advise Clients Year-Round

Employee benefits group captives give brokers greater insight, expanded resources, and new opportunities to deliver value beyond the annual renewal.
Sponsored by Innovative Captive Strategies Posted on November 17, 2026

A benefits captive solution creates an opportunity to look beyond the next renewal by providing greater visibility into the claims experience, helping identify cost trends, and giving employers the opportunity to benefit from favorable performance.

For brokers, that means shifting from reacting to an annual renewal to helping clients understand and manage their healthcare strategy throughout the year.

Ashley Mataloni, vice president of employee benefits at Innovative Captive Strategies, says employers should weigh the long-term commitment when comparing first-year premiums. “[A benefits captive] is not a one-year play,” she says. The decision goes beyond finding the “lowest [premium] on the spreadsheet.”  As Mataloni puts it, “It’s really something that’s going to require their engagement and accountability.”

That long-term approach changes the broker-client dynamic. With greater access to data, expertise, and strategic resources, brokers can help clients understand what is driving their healthcare costs and identify opportunities to act.

From Passive Placement to Active Consulting

As Mataloni points out, in the traditional market, benefits conversations often center on the renewal: the rate increase, what is driving it, and how costs might be absorbed or distributed differently. A captive creates a different conversation. Access to claims and performance data allows brokers to help clients identify cost drivers and make more informed decisions about plan design and benefits strategy.

That requires an understanding of the self-funded model on which a benefits captive is built. Stop-loss, underwriting, pharmacy strategy, and population health and plan administration can all become important parts of the conversation. But brokers do not have to develop all of that expertise on their own.

Mataloni notes ICS acts as an extension of the broker team, providing captive education, underwriting and proposal guidance, claims analytics, benchmark reporting, population health insights, and access to specialized stop-loss, pharmacy, clinical, and administrative resources. The broker remains the trusted advisor, while bringing in broader expertise from ICS as well as bringing in specialists as the client needs them.

“The best consultants know how to bring the right experts into play,” Mataloni says. “There’s a lot that’s specific to the captive success that an adviser needs expertise in—and if it’s not internal to that advisor, it’s at least accessible to the advisor.”

Worth the Effort

Consider pharmacy spend. One ICS captive member discovered that a single high-cost prescription represented approximately $600,000 annually, or about 30% of its healthcare claims. The captive structure gave the employer greater flexibility to select a TPA and access an alternative PBM solution. That strategy ultimately contributed to more than $850,000 in pharmacy savings in the first year. A more active consulting role in the client relationship creates value for the broker as well. Mataloni explains that this approach often expands benefits conversations beyond HR and finance, bringing senior leadership into discussions about the organization’s overall healthcare strategy.

It also gives brokers more opportunities to demonstrate their value outside of renewal season. Rather than simply responding to market conditions, brokers can help clients connect those insights with focused strategies.

Over time, that year-round collaboration can strengthen the broker-client relationship and reinforce the broker’s role as a strategic advisor. It also gives brokers a more meaningful story to tell prospective clients: not simply how they place coverage, but how they help employers make more informed benefit decisions.

“I think the advisors that are willing to put in the work to get captive clients, knowing that it’s not the path of least resistance, helps them differentiate,” Mataloni says. “That can help them grow their book of business more quickly because they’re proving to be more impactful to their clients, and word of mouth is a powerful thing as well.”

More in Health+Benefits

Use Dental Plan Data for Smarter Renewals
Health+Benefits Use Dental Plan Data for Smarter Renewals
Strategic dental plan design helps cut costs, not value, and makes renewal conve...
Sponsored By Ameritas
Health+Benefits All Eyes on Healthcare
Federal healthcare laws and regulations enacted in recent years face serious obs...
Leverage Dental Benefits for Greater Health Outcomes
Health+Benefits Leverage Dental Benefits for Greater Health Outcomes
Carrier expertise and insights into employee behavior can help emphasize dental ...
Sponsored By Ameritas