Use Dental Plan Data for Smarter Renewals
If benefit renewals have taught us anything this year, it’s that insurance carriers and brokers need better strategies to help employers and employees lower costs.
Dental benefits are a great place to start. Plans that balance premium cost with employees’ out-of-pocket expenses perform better throughout the year, making dental renewals easier for you and your clients.
“Cost is not just about dental plan premium,” says JoAnn Davis, divisional vice president of national accounts for group dental and vision insurance at Ameritas. “Our job is to show employers how the right plan designs create better long-term cost outcomes than short-term premium cuts.”
Consider Total Program Cost
While reducing coverage or raising deductibles lower dental plan rates, they also decrease the plan’s overall value by increasing out-of-pocket costs for employees. They’ll feel this when they begin using their benefits.
“When you look at the total dental program cost,” Davis says, “you see how plan adjustments that cut premium affect member expenses throughout the year, degrading member satisfaction.”
There’s a better strategy than simply cutting coverage and shifting costs to employees. The key, Davis says, is to ensure plan adjustments to control premium costs also align with employees’ dental care needs and the way they use their coverage.
Design Plans Around Employee Behavior
Group dental plan reports show benefits usage trends that can inform potential shifts in plan design. Dental benefits carriers can help identify behavior patterns to focus on when preparing for renewals.
“Perio is a great place to start,” Davis says. “If periodontic procedure utilization is low for the group, and their employee population is generally younger, moving perio to a lower coverage level can decrease premium without increasing most employees’ out-of-pocket costs.”
Review the percentage of employees who reach their dental benefit annual maximum. Groups with claims focused on preventive care may be able to lower their maximum at renewal with minimal employee impact since few reach their benefit limits.
Groups with a varied or older population should cover more expensive restorative procedures. Instead of letting that coverage inflate plan cost, offering multiple plans that meet different employee needs helps stabilize plan costs and performance.
“Giving employees options drives people to the right plan,” Davis says, “which can save money in the long run by helping to control utilization and claims. Plan choice also increases participation and makes for a better employee experience.”
Leverage Network Discounts
Another trend to look for within group reporting is network provider use. If most employees visit network dentists, decreasing out-of-network coverage at renewal reduces plan costs with minimal disruption.
“That change also encourages more members to visit network dentists and pay less out of pocket,” Davis says, “which lowers overall claim costs. That looks good at renewal and helps keep premium down over time, so you don’t have to cut coverage.”
To make this strategy most effective, Davis says, the network discount must be good, and employees must use it.
“Ameritas network discounts are guaranteed to be 25% to 50% lower than the dentist’s regular rates,” Davis says. “To increase access, we recruit network providers based on the dentists our customers visit and the areas where they need them.”
Ameritas also encourages benefits and network use through employee education—not just at enrollment or renewal, but all year.
“Year-round education makes for a better conversation at renewal,” Davis says. “Employees who see the impact of network discounts are more likely to use their benefits and visit network providers. That boost in preventive care and network utilization helps lower plan costs.”
Control Costs in 2027
Employers will count on insurance carriers and brokers to assist them in managing benefits costs in 2027. Dental renewal strategies based on total program cost—not just premium—make those conversations easier and more positive.
“Dental is a feel-good benefit that employees rely on to stay healthy and save money,” Davis says. “Brokers can also use it as a tool to ease cost pressures at renewal. Ameritas is here to help design total dental program cost strategies.”




