Lifestyle Reader's Edge the Jan/Feb 2022 issue

Fiction Therapy for Our Jittery Souls

A Review of The Best American Short Stories of 2021
By Scott Naugle Posted on January 18, 2022

Our attention spans are muddled and over-Zoomed, masked and needled, but we can recover through fiction, a paragraph at a time. In The Best American Short Stories of 2021, editor Jesmyn Ward assembles 20 of the finest examples of short fiction written and published over the past year, a therapeutic for our jittery souls.

The Best American Short Stories of 2021

Edited by Jesmyn Ward

Mariner Books/An Imprint of HarperCollins


Ward is an exquisite literary sommelier. Barely in her forties, she was awarded the National Book Award for Fiction twice, first in 2011 for Salvage the Bones and again in 2017 for Sing, Unburied, Sing. Ward is also the recipient of a MacArthur Genius Grant. A professor of creative writing at Tulane University, she was recently widowed and is raising two young children from her hometown of Delisle, Mississippi, on the Gulf Coast.

In Ward’s introduction, she explains, “Throughout this terrible pandemic…story sustained us, and we gripped the planks of narrative so that in the immersion into story, we might have togetherness and hope and drama and laughter and beauty, might revel in all that binds us together as human.”

In the story Our Children by Vanessa Cuti, a chance encounter while shopping tears apart two marriages: “I met Dan at the grocery store. In the produce section, feeling sweet potatoes. I don’t know that many people think to feel sweet potatoes. But, I do, and so did Dan that day luckily enough.” From the interior voice of the female narrator, never named, we enter a world that on the surface should be perfect—large homes, new cars, each with two young children—masking a discontent, weariness perhaps, over the passionless throbbing of time.

There is, I think, a sadness shrouding the story, an enveloping fog of lethargic remorse. Without existential mooring, the characters react to impulse.

On a weekend trip to a wilderness cabin with their blended family of four children, Dan and the narrator awaken in the middle of the night while the young children sleep. “We have to leave them here,” she says. “Not forever. Maybe we come back for them. When they’ve grown a little, found their way. Do you understand what our lives will be like?” They drive away together in the darkness leaving the young children.

Fiction as Door to DE&I

As we struggle with building diversity, equity and inclusion within our brokerages and industry, fiction may offer a path to gaining a sense of empathy at how others encounter the world and why they may react as they do.

Jenzo Duque, in The Rest of Us, introduces a young mixed-ethnicity narrator who describes his limitations within the inner city of Chicago that may subtly suggest a metaphor for his future in an unjust world. “Ours was not a world of exploration. We knew its boundaries well. Two blocks south was Cobra’s territory…Muslims and Jews to the north. The white people all lived east by the Lakefront, they always did and always will.”

He has hard-working parents, struggling to provide the basics of a roof and food. “For a while we didn’t have to worry about the world beyond our gated lawns. Our parents did their best to hide us from the alleyways and trap houses, from the vatos with tattoos crawling up their thick necks.”

You know the rest of the story. Drugs. Arrests. Jail. But, if you read closely, it is possible to empathize, to step inside another experience and feel the disparity of choices, the desperation, and the inevitability of the result. Thoughtful readers will step away from The Rest of Us and think twice about circumstances and stereotypes.

Ward does not hint at an overarching theme tying the stories together, but I’d suggest one of transcendence. In most of the stories, someone is in transition, physically or emotionally, attempting to land in a softer place. “In these tales, the surprise of the flowering of a human being, the evolution of character, reminds me that this too can be true of human beings in real life. At the same time that we are capable of devolution in private and public life, we are also capable of empathetic evolution and change,” affirms Ward in closing her introduction to The Best American Short Stories of 2021.

More in Lifestyle

Greg Kinnear
Lifestyle Greg Kinnear
Who cares what the policy says if the agent is good looking?
Lifestyle Wanderlust: Africa 
The idea of a wild African safari may seem fleeting to some, but this worthwhile...
A Novel in Disguise
Lifestyle A Novel in Disguise
Review of The Last Suspicious Holdout: Stories
John Nelson, Co-CEO, Warner Pacific
Lifestyle John Nelson, Co-CEO, Warner Pacific
“It has been a 35-year college education for me, so it’s challenging in that...
Rotem Iram, Founder and CEO, At-Bay
Lifestyle Rotem Iram, Founder and CEO, At-Bay
“The truth is, I trust my people more than I trust myself....
Phil Collins
Lifestyle Phil Collins
SIUs and creepy tin clowns—the colorful side of insurance....